Carroll Citizen’s Group Opposes Proposed Rosebud Coal Mine and Coal Washing Facilities

In CategoryCounter Coalture Coalition

It makes me feel good when a community comes together to protect their land and surrounding area.  A group of Carrol county citizens came out in force to oppose  a proposed coal mine in their county.   It’s good to see that there are still people in the world that care about the future.  In todays’ society most people would take a buyout and move away from the problem with no concern of what happens to the area.  I for one am glad to see that people still care.

Below is a copy of the press release from the meeting.



MARCH 11, 2010

Carroll Citizen’s Group Opposes Proposed Rosebud Coal Mine and Coal Washing Facilities
Residents of Union Township and surrounding areas in Carroll County met to voice their opposition to a
proposed Rosebud Mining Company coal mine. Many of nearly 30 people who met recently at the
Friendship Center had been part of the 60+ people who were at the January Ohio Department of Natural
Resources (ODNR) Division of Mineral Resource Management public comment meeting where they
formally submitted their concerns.

The consensus of the attendees at both meetings was that Rosebud’s proposed mining operations will
reward an out-of-state corporation at the expense of Carroll County property owners and government.
Few if any local jobs will be created and no substantial tax revenues are expected by the County.
Subsidence and water issues that are part of this type of mining and are likely to plague the County’s
citizens and government for generations to come. SR 332 will become a dangerous heavy-truck
trafficked highway, and, that the proposed mine would negatively impact Carroll County’s rural
environment and drive down land values.

Dominick Olivito Jr., who lives directly across the street from the proposed mine portal, expressed his
concerns, saying “like many of us, I moved here over 30 years ago, raised a family, and planned to retire
here to enjoy the peaceful surroundings, fresh air, clean water and rural lifestyle. There is a very real
probability that the mining operation will affect our well water quality, quantity or both. Without good
water property values will go down and that’s not good for fellow landowners or the County.”

Rosebud Mining Company acknowledged at a public meeting last fall that Carroll County is unique in
that it has low population density and most of its residents rely on wells for domestic and agricultural
water needs. Mr. Olivito continued, “Rosebud’s permit application demonstrates there has been
inadequately analysis of the aquifers that provide our well water and how a 20+ year mining operation
will impact those aquifers.”

Paul Feezel, who coordinated the follow-up meeting, said that “most Union Township landowners
expect the mining operations will do more harm than good to the County.” Feezel and others in the
group have used the Freedom of Information act to request records from State and Local officials in an
effort to understand who is really benefiting from this operation. The proposed room and pillar mining
operation is similar to those that have been making the news in Tuscarawas where subsidence (sink
holes) and well water issues are forcing home owners to resort to lawsuits and state funding to cover
their losses. “My wife and I just finished building our eco-friendly retirement home and the potential of
losing our water or even our house just makes us sick to our stomachs. The State’s limited subsidence
insurance couldn’t come close to paying for our home’s replacement.” said Feezel.

Linda Jordan, the lone Harrison County representative at the meeting, encouraged the group, saying
“it’s great to see so many folks from Carroll County who care about the impact of this operation. In Scio,
where the coal washing plant is planned, too many residents have just resigned themselves to giving
Rosebud whatever they want.” Rosebud has asked the State to invoke a rarely used economic
development law to side step a local North Township no-landfill ordinance. Jordan who lives near the
proposed wash plant location said that she worries the landfill liner used to hold the toxic waste from
the coal washing facility has a year life expectancy of only 30-50 years. “Thirty years may seem like a
long time to Rosebud,” said Jordan, “but not to folks who would like to pass something on to their

Harrison County has first-hand experience with the benefits and costs of coal mining. Jodan continued, “I
realize that coal is a strong part of local history, but the evidence is all around us. Coal makes a few
people rich, allows a few more to survive for a while, but what is left to the next generation? If coal was
really the great economic answer, then based upon past activity here, Harrison County should be the
richest county in the state.”

Dominick Olivito, Jr. summed up the meeting with a call to action. “Now is the time for Carroll County
property owners to defend their water and property rights by working with ODNR and against Rosebud
or other mining concerns. We need to say, no thank you Rosebud, we prefer Carroll County the way it

The group will hold its next monthly meeting on Monday March 29 at 7:00 PM at the Friendship Center
near the Carroll County Fairgrounds. The meeting is open to the public; however to coordinate meeting
logistics, anyone interested in attending is asked contact Paul Feezel at 330-627-7163 in advance.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.